Wikipedia is better than Brockhaus EncyclopediaDecember 6, 2007 at 6:13 am | Posted in Web 2.0 | 2 Comments
Tags: Brockhaus, Comparison, encyclopedia, Encyclopedia Britannica, Wikipedia
That is to say: German Wikipedia is better than Brockhaus online, the latter being the German equivalent to the Encyclopedia Britannica, a comparison conducted by German magazine Stern has shown. They cross-checked 50 randomly selected entries (“Hartz IV”, “U2”, “Penicillin” or “Moses”) and gave marks for Accuracy, Currency and Ease of Understanding.
The results: 43 Wikipedia articles were “better” than Brockhaus’s, mainly for reasons of currency _and_ (surprise!) currency. Brockhaus, for instance, did neither know about Pararotti’s death nor about the Noble Prize for Doris Lessing.
Too bad the study didn’t give examples of accuracy, as it would have been interesting to know their notion of accuracy.
What I thought was surprising: Brockhaus, even though NOT written by laymen, was easier to understand. It seems as if Wikipedians like to impress with elaborate sentences and exclusive terminology:-)